Tales from the Borderlands oli yksi Telltale Gamesin yllätyshiteistä, ja peli saavutti uskollisen fanikunnan kautta maailman. Jatkoa ei koskaan saatu, mutta Gearbox olisi itse kiinnostunut tekemään kakkoskauden.
Asian paljasti Borderlands 3:n tarinoija Sam Winkler Comic Bookille.
"I would love to pick up where Tales from the Borderlands Season 1 left off. There's so many unsolved threads there, and even though we brought some characters into Borderlands 3, there's still a lot of question marks. I am a die-hard fan of Tales, and I inserted some winks and nods that are probably going to drive some fan wiki articles."